Blame

Standard

All I have been hearing over the past few days is outrage over the Casey Anthony verdict. And I get it – I do. It is outrageous that a woman who most likely killed her child is walking free. I’m outraged, too. But we need to think twice about who we blame. I’m not sure who is to blame. Did the prosecutors not do a good enough job? Maybe. Should we blame the defense? No – they were doing their job. One thing I know – we shouldn’t be blaming the jury, and yet that’s what I am seeing time and time again.

Having been on a jury for a somewhat high profile, criminal trial, I feel for those jurors. You’re puled away from your normal life and thrown into an emotionally charged, high pressure, absolutely exhausting situation and the whole world (or the whole country or state or city or even just the victim’s family) is looking to you todo something – to fix it. You might be able to deliver a guilty verdict – the thing everyone is hoping for- but even if you do, it doesn’t fix it. The crime was still committed. What was done is still done.

But after a horrible crime, the only thing left to cling to is that guilty verdict – putting the bad guy in prison or on death row. That’s a lot of pressure for the average person. It was a lot of pressure for me. I was on a jury for a kidnapping/rape trial. It was exhausting and heart wrenching. You are supposed to be neutral, but it’s impossible not to look at the victim and their family and feel their pain, even just a little. You want to do what’s right for them, but your job is to do what’s right for everyone – what’s right for the justice system, and sadly they aren’t always the same thing.

There are a lot of things wrong with our justice system – trials are delayed, courts get mired in ridiculous lawsuits, evidence is mishandled and worst of all (to me) are the completely ass-backward sentences. Many child molesters spend less than a year in prison. Rapists serve about 6 years on average. And yet you commit a monetary crime and the sentence is longer than many murderers serve. Jim Bakker received 45 years for embezzlement. Now, I’m not saying that financial crimes don’t deserve a tough punishment – they do. But what does it say about our society when an embezzler gets 45 years and a child molester gets less than one?

So yes – our justice system isn’t perfect. But the juries are not to blame. The juries are just doing their job to the best of their abilities. Juries aren’t made up of legal experts and psychologists and social workers. Juries are made up of teachers and mechanics and engineers and students and housewives and grandfathers. Some are educated, some aren’t. Some have kids, some don’t. Some will cry along with the victims, some won’t feel a thing. but the one thing they (usually) have in common is that they want to do a good job. They want to do what’s right. And sometimes what’s right isn’t what what they want or feel or what is best for the victims.

At the trial I was on, there were 21 counts – ranging from rape and other sexual charges to robbery to kidnapping. We easily found him guilty on 20 of those charges. But the 21st charge threw us for a loop. It was a weapons charge, and while you would think that the kidnap/rape charges would be more important, this was a big one. This charge meant a HUGE increase in jail time. And I’m sure the victim & her family were disappointed to hear the not guilty verdict on that one charge, we did what we had to do.

Every single one of us felt that he was guilty – that he had had a weapon (a big scary knife). But as a juror, it is your job to take what you feel out of it and base your decision on the evidence. And the evidence wasn’t there. The prosecution couldn’t prove to us beyond a reasonable doubt that a weapon was used and we couldn’t come back with a guilty verdict. It sucked. But it was also the right thing to do.

Our justice system has problems – I know that. But not because the juries aren’t trying to do their job and do it right. After hearing all the evidence, the juries are given their instructions, and those instructions are very clear about evidence and testimony and reasonable doubt. And you go into that room wanting to do what is best for the victim, what’s best for society and still follow the rules. It’s a lot of pressure. And often, outsiders – people who complain about the outcome – haven’t heard all the evidence. Or the jury’s instructions. And most off all, they are basing their opinion on their emotions – their outrage. Not on reasonable doubt.

When I read news stories about how the jurors in the Anthony trial are being threatened, that the courts have to protect them from possible harm, it makes me sad. Don’t blame the juries – they are doing the best they can with what they are given. And while sometimes the verdict isn’t what we all want or think is warranted, the system is set up the way it is for a reason. And I for one, believe in it. Because as much as I hate the idea of the guilty going free, I hate the idea of the innocent being convicted even more.

Advertisements

About sugarmag

Forty-sdjhfkjsdhfkjsdh year old mom of 2 - a 18 year old boy and a 11 year old girl. I love them very much, but they drive me crazy. I'm married and work full-time. I'm not sure which of these is the most exhausting, but probably the husband. I'm opinionated. I'm outspoken. I'm loud. I'm an over-sharer. I think Tom Cruise is a jackass. I like to say jackass. I like to swear, period. Fuckers. I love to read. I struggle with my weight. I love my job. I dress my pets up and ridicule them regularly. I am not afraid to cut my hair and I don't understand people who are. I hate getting old. I love to laugh. Make me laugh, OK?

5 responses »

  1. Here's my beef with this whole case. We only know what the media told us. The media was shoving this in our face and knew they were causing emotions to flare.Do i think she did it? Yes. Am i all upset and ready to harm someone over it? hell no. Its none of my business. Unless you were in that courtroom you have no idea how this played out.People need to tone down the extreme rage they've been showing over everything.Besides, she'll meet her maker someday and face the ultimate judgement.

  2. With the information I have about the case, I believe she killed her little girl. But I am sure I don't have all the information nor do have the instructions to the jury.I don't think the jury should be blamed for doing their jobs, their civic duty.I am outraged that she was able to get away with it, but she will have to live with this on her conscience (if she has one) and it will come back to bite her butt one day.

  3. I just did a post on the Anthony trial yesterday and came at it in a similar fashion. That people are blaming and threatening the jury is sickening. They did what they had to do, given the evidence presented. (Or lack thereof.)People are actually saying that if they were on the jury, they would have held out to purposefully make a hung jury, so that the prosecution could get a do-over and make a better case.That's not due-process, that's something that schoolkids do on a playground.There's a reason we have to prove a case "beyond a reasonable doubt."Casey Anthony is going to have to live with the repercussions. And I don't think it's going to be that long. Karma is a bitch.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s